Comparisons · 5 min read

Coal Tar vs. Asphalt Emulsion: Which Sealcoat is Right for Your Placentia Driveway?

Choosing the right Sealcoat for your Placentia driveway can be a big decision. All Star Asphalt Company is here to help homeowners in Placentia, CA understand the main options available. We will break down the differences between coal tar Sealcoat and asphalt emulsion Sealcoat. This information will help you make a good choice for your property. All Star Asphalt Company provides Sealcoating services for driveways in Placentia, CA.

← Back to Blog Completed asphalt sealcoating work at a residential property in Placentia, CA

Alright, let us talk about Sealcoating. You have an Asphalt driveway here in Placentia, CA, and you want to keep it looking good and lasting a long time. That is a smart decision. Our Southern California sun, especially those very hot summer days we get out towards the 57 Freeway, can really beat up Pavement. You are probably wondering what the best material to put on it is, and there are two main products you will hear about: Coal Tar Emulsion and Asphalt Emulsion. All Star Asphalt Company helps homeowners in Placentia, CA understand these options.

All Star Asphalt Company has been in this business for a long time, and we have seen both of these products in action. They both do the job of protecting your Asphalt from UV rays, water, and oil spills. However, they do it a little differently. Let us break down the real-world differences so you can figure out what makes the most sense for your home in Placentia, CA. All Star Asphalt Company provides Sealcoating services in Placentia, CA.

Coal Tar Emulsion: The Traditional Heavy Hitter

Coal Tar has been the go-to for Sealcoating for many decades. It is a byproduct of processing coal, and it creates a very tough, hard barrier on your driveway. Think of it like a very durable shell. All Star Asphalt Company understands Coal Tar Emulsion for Placentia, CA properties.

Pros:

  • Durability and Resistance: This is where Coal Tar really performs well. It is incredibly resistant to things like oil, gasoline, and other chemicals that can drip from your car. If you have a leaky old classic car in your garage, Coal Tar will stand up to those spills better than other options. It also holds up exceptionally well against UV rays and water penetration.
  • Longevity: You can expect a Coal Tar Sealcoat to last a good 3 to 5 years, sometimes even longer, before needing reapplication. That means fewer applications over time, which can be a good thing.
  • Appearance: It dries to a deep, rich black color that looks fantastic and really makes your driveway stand out.
  • Cost (Upfront): Sometimes, the material cost for Coal Tar can be a little less upfront, though this is changing with regulations.

Cons:

  • Environmental and Health Concerns: This is the most important concern. Coal Tar contains high levels of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), which are known carcinogens. These can be released into the environment and have raised some serious health and environmental red flags. Because of this, some states and municipalities have banned its use.
  • Odor: It has a strong, distinct smell during application and curing that can linger for some time.
  • Brittleness: While it is hard, it can become brittle over time, especially in colder climates, which can lead to cracking. Though here in Placentia, CA, we do not get much freezing weather, the intense heat can still cause issues with a less flexible material.

Asphalt Emulsion: The Modern, Environmentally Friendly Choice

Asphalt Emulsion Sealers are made from Asphalt, just like your driveway, mixed with water and emulsifiers. This makes it a more environmentally conscious option. All Star Asphalt Company offers Asphalt Emulsion Sealcoating for Placentia, CA homes.

Pros:

  • Environmentally Friendly and Safer: This is its biggest advantage. Asphalt Emulsion has significantly lower levels of VOCs (volatile organic compounds) and PAHs, making it much safer for your family, your pets, and the environment. There are no strong, lingering odors either.
  • Flexibility: Because it is made from the same material as your driveway, it tends to expand and contract better with temperature changes. This flexibility can help prevent premature cracking, which is a real benefit with our fluctuating Southern California temperatures.
  • Application: It is generally easier to apply and can be used in a wider range of temperatures than Coal Tar. It also dries to a true, deep black finish.
  • Good Adhesion: It bonds naturally with your existing Asphalt surface.

Cons:

  • Chemical Resistance: It is not quite as resistant to oil and gasoline spills as Coal Tar. While modern formulations are improving, you might need to clean up spills quicker.
  • Shorter Lifespan: Typically, Asphalt Emulsion needs reapplication every 1 to 3 years, which is a bit more frequent than Coal Tar. This means more frequent maintenance, though the application process is generally quicker.
  • Cost (Long-term): While the material cost might be comparable or slightly higher upfront, the more frequent applications can make the long-term cost a bit higher than Coal Tar, depending on the product and how much traffic the driveway sees.

My Recommendation for Placentia Homeowners

Given our conditions here in Placentia, CA, with plenty of sun and generally moderate temperatures (though we do get those hot spells), and considering the residential nature of most driveways, All Star Asphalt Company leans towards Asphalt Emulsion Sealcoating for homeowners in Placentia, CA.

Here is why:

  • Environmental and Health Safety: This is an important consideration, especially for residential properties where kids and pets might be playing. You do not want those PAHs hanging around your home.
  • Flexibility in Our Climate: The ability of Asphalt Emulsion to flex with temperature changes is a huge plus. While we do not have harsh freezes, the expansion and contraction from our hot days and cooler nights can still stress a brittle Sealcoat.
  • Appearance: It still gives you that beautiful, rich black finish that enhances curb appeal.

Yes, you might need to reseal a little more often, perhaps every 2 to 3 years. However, the peace of mind knowing you are using a safer, more environmentally friendly product is worth it. Most residential driveways are not seeing the kind of heavy chemical spills that commercial lots do, so the slightly lower chemical resistance is not usually a deal-breaker for a homeowner in Placentia, CA. All Star Asphalt Company provides Sealcoating services in Placentia, CA.

No matter which Sealcoating product you choose, proper preparation is important. That means cleaning the surface thoroughly and addressing any cracks or potholes before the Sealcoat goes down. If you skip that step, neither product will perform its best. All Star Asphalt Company always makes sure to do that right for our customers in Placentia, CA.

So, for your Placentia, CA home, go with Asphalt Emulsion. You will get great protection, a sharp look, and you can feel good about your choice for your family and the local environment. If you have questions or want to get a quote, give All Star Asphalt Company a call. All Star Asphalt Company provides Sealcoating services to all areas in and around Placentia, CA.

Ready to Get Started in Placentia?

Contact All Star Asphalt Company today for a free, no-obligation estimate on your project.

Get Your Free Quote